Overdraft fees are one of the top four reasons customers don’t bank with their current financial institution. So why does it exist? Biden’s new proposal is to cut overdraft by 50% and give banks 2 billion less in revenue, but he gives them a 3-year reprieve on taking that money out of customer accounts.
The “how much did banks make in overdraft fees in 2020” is a question that has been asked by many. The Biden Administration wants to stop the banks from making so much money off of overdraft fees.
WASHINGTON— Banks are under fresh regulatory pressure to change their overdraft-fee policies, which generate billions of dollars in income from cash-strapped customers.
Through a combination of public warnings and potential new regulation, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, which oversees national banks, are pressuring financial institutions to reduce what officials describe as an overreliance on overdraft fees. Making it easy for people to shift money and their account histories to banks with reduced costs is one of the rules being considered.
Consumers are charged these fees by banks and other financial organizations when they make payments that exceed the amount in their checking accounts. According to the authorities, low-income households are disproportionately affected by the fees, which wreak havoc on their budgets while generating billions of dollars for banks.
More than a decade after the Federal Reserve established a regulation prohibiting banks from collecting fees automatically when customers overdraw their accounts, the fees have emerged as a regulatory worry. Customers must opt in to “overdraft protection” programs before they can be charged, meaning they must agree to pay a fee when they overdraw their accounts at automated teller machines or with most debit-card transactions, according to the rule, which is now overseen by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.
According to Moebs Services Inc., which tracks roughly 3,000 banks, credit unions, fintechs, and other companies, financial institutions are on track to collect nearly $33 billion in fee revenue this year from transactions that result in consumers overdrawing or having insufficient funds in their deposit accounts, up 5% from last year. Fees have remained below $37.1 billion since 2009, when the Fed first adopted its restriction.
Using data from big banks and estimations from smaller lenders, the CFPB predicts that the industry’s overall income from such fees climbed by an average of 1.7 percent per year from 2015 to 2019, totaling $15.5 billion in 2019.
Acting Comptroller of the Currency Michael Hsu has urged banks to change their charge policies in order to improve customer financial health. In a speech on Wednesday, he warned that fees intended to be used sparingly have instead become common and recurrent for a very small percentage of financially fragile bank clients.
In an interview, he added, “What I’ve been urging bankers is, ‘Do the right thing,’ because you want your dependence to be on revenues you feel good about.” “This is one of the issues with typical overdrafts.” It’s legal, yet it does harm to individuals.”
Most customers, according to the Consumer Bankers Association, see the option to overdraw after consenting to a charge as a benefit.
Bloomberg News/Bloomberg/Daniel Tepper
Some customers, according to banks, want to get their transactions completed even if it means overdrawing and paying a cost. They also claim that the capacity to overdraw acts as a type of short-term credit for individuals with little funds who have trouble getting credit.
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau said this month that it will pursue large banks that depend on overdraft fees. JPMorgan Chase & Co., Wells Fargo & Co., and Bank of America Corp. BAC 0.07 percent were identified as responsible for a significant portion of overall overdraft and non-sufficient funds charge income received by banks with more than $1 billion in assets.
When customers bounce checks or make bill payments that exceed their account balances, they are charged non-sufficient funds fines. The Fed’s opt-in rule does not apply to these transactions.
According to S&P Global Market Intelligence, overdraft charge income at JPMorgan Chase was $1.46 billion in 2020, $1.28 billion at Wells Fargo, and $1.11 billion at Bank of America. Due to the coronavirus outbreak, banks gave overdraft charge exemptions and other fee concessions, lowering the statistics from a year before.
Clients benefit from the opportunity to overdraw, according to a JPMorgan spokesperson, who added that the bank has aided customers by raising the amount they may overdraw without paying a charge. Wells Fargo stated in a statement that it offers a product with no overdraft fees and that it provides tools to assist clients manage their accounts. Bank of America did not respond to a request for comment.
Director Rohit Chopra of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau said he has directed the bureau’s enforcement lawyers and examiners to focus on banks’ overdraft abuses. He believes that the persistence of high overdraft fees implies a lack of competition in banking services.
Mr. Chopra said in a written statement that “rather than competing on excellent service and competitive interest rates, many banks have gotten addicted to overdraft fees to sustain their business model.” “We will take steps to bring significant competition back to this industry.”
According to Moebs Services, overdraft fees vary per institution and average $30 per transaction so far this year.
A number of major banks have lately altered their overdraft policy. Capital One Financial Corp., which charges $35 when clients overdraw, said that overdraft fees would be phased out early next year, while non-sufficient funds fines will be phased out in August. Overdraft fees were discontinued by Ally Financial Inc. in the spring.
Transactions that exceed a customer’s account balance may be processed at the bank’s discretion. Consumers would be responsible for repaying the amount they overdrew.
Customers will have until the end of the following business day to refill their bank accounts, according to JPMorgan. To avoid these costs, customers will be able to receive monies from their direct-deposited payroll payments sooner than usual.
LET US KNOW WHAT YOU’RE CONCERNED ABOUT.
Should overdraft fees on consumer checking accounts be eliminated? Participate in the discussion below.
The revisions might be part of a larger shift away from fees, which have been collected by banks for decades. In a research released this month, Ken Usdin, a bank analyst at Jefferies, stated, “It is probable that incidence rates and per-instance pricing will come under directional pressure over time.”
According to the Jefferies analysis, overdraft fees and other associated charges accounted for a median of 1.4 percent of banks’ income in the third quarter. Fees accounted for 2% of Wells Fargo’s income, 1.4 percent of Bank of America’s, and 1% of JPMorgan’s.
According to a research issued this month by data supplier Curinos and the Consumer Bankers Association, the majority of customers see opt-in as useful and use it consciously to pay unexpected expenditures in times of need.
Financial disparities in consumer banking have been noted in other studies. According to a 2017 CFPB survey, over 20% of consumers who routinely overdraw don’t have a credit score. Most persons without credit scores are unable to get mainstream, inexpensive financing. Separately, according to the Pew Charitable Trusts, persons who regularly experience overdraft fees have low incomes.
According to Aaron Klein, a senior scholar at the Brookings Institution, “the less money you have, the more costly it is to access your money.”
AnnaMaria Andriotis and Andrew Ackerman can be reached at [email protected] and [email protected], respectively.
Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Copyright 2021 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. 87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8
Watch This Video-
Overdraft fees have been a major issue for banks. The Biden administration wants to reduce the number of predatory overdraft fees.
Related Tags
- how much did banks make in overdraft fees in 2021
- two more regional banks are rethinking overdraft fees
- how much do banks make in overdraft fees
- why are overdraft fees so high
- why do banks charge overdraft fees
